Evelyn the Fate
That's a good method of doing profiles. I also think we need to clear up a lot of old junk around this guild. There's a lot of junk threads that are just taking up space and cluttering our eyes and pages.
Agreed... I'm not entirely sure about the idea of wings... you can't really have wings unless you have a manor, or castle of sorts. So perhaps the main thread could be devoted to announcements, Guild activities such as events and competitions.
As you pointed out though, the arguments in an all out free-for-all would be a bad thing, we don't want that, so perhaps the mods could be set to referee matches, maybe there would be a prize or something at the end, but that wouldn't be announced until all the matches were over so no body started getting "desperate" as you put it.
Maybe our prize would just be knowing we got luckier than everyone else. That'd be fine with me.