Welcome to Gaia! ::

Inkblotters: Poetry and Critique Mentoring

Back to Guilds

 

 

Reply Working With the Mentors (Mentor Threads)
Aged Cherry Twizzlers never had it so good. Enter. Goto Page: 1 2 [>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Hoodimann

PostPosted: Wed Jul 25, 2007 1:57 pm


Hi, ACT.

Welcome to the jungle. No machete required; no gnats to swat.

I'm taking a slightly different approach with you.

Here's the deal. If you read this post before I edited it, then forget the original requests made of you.

I would like to know two things.

Is there a specific thing you'd like to begin with?

How familiar are you with form poetry....and which forms are you familiar with? (I'd say "familiar" is having written at least three poems in the form...without altering the form to suit your newness to it!)

If you say you've written two sestinas, but in one of them you varied the forms of the end words, then you wrote one sestina, and one...something else.

I intend on being inflexible at first, regarding criteria. After you've shown that you really understand what a form is asking of you, then you can make changes to it which raise the form higher, not dismantle it because it's easier to not follow the rules.

So. With all that in mind, I hope I don't seem too bull-headed to assist. It's my sincere hope that I can help you improve every aspect of your writing, without using cookie-cutter techniques.

Post a couple samples of whichever form poems you've done. Two per form. Do not write anything new to meet this...show me what you've already written, so that I gain perspective. (If you've only done free verse or blank verse, then don't post any poetry. Merely choose one of these three forms to learn: pantoum, sestina, villanelle. Yes...there are assloads of other forms, which we will cover...we'll move to sonnets, haiku and another after you've done these three, and we'll work in groups of three forms, just because I like the number three, and like having reasons to have groups of three.) xd

Later.

Hoodi.
PostPosted: Thu Jul 26, 2007 8:17 am


cool, i'm excited!

as to your first question, no. wherever you want to start is fine with me, seeing as how you're the teacher and all. as to your second question, the only forms i'm anywhere near familiar with are the sestina, the villanelle, and the sonnet. i've written one or two things in other forms, but those three are the ones i've dabbled in most.


here are the samples you requested, although i have to say only one of them comes anywhere close to not embarrassing me. (the reason i didn't post any sonnets is because i wrote a sonnet redoublé, and it's hella long. but if you want the link i can post it.)

Before you break

Indeed, she's always braced her knees to push
her way from my cocoon, as paper-thin
as she must feel each time she's told to shush.

A mother's love, the veins that show full-flush--
she kicks them, arm-leg-arm, runs out of limbs.
Indeed, she's always braced her knees to push

and form a gap. With thick red streaks she thrusts
away. I feel, with each drunk needle's limn,
as she must feel each time she's told to shush.

She's home at last, her wings spread wide in trust,
tattoo exposed for loverboy. "It's him"
indeed. She's always braced her knees to push.

This boy, he flutters towards her, just a crush
that's got her pinned for sure, fresh through the skin--
as she must feel each time she's told to shush.

The two of them will never know the rush
of flying free within the womb. "Begin"
indeed. She's always braced her knees, to push
as she must feel each time she's told to shush.


Bear down


My vision, hazed, runs thick with liquid tar—
such honey, black and sweet, that floods the comb
to seal my window where it sits ajar.

I clench the mattress, swelling in alarm,
and fingers sink as if through cream or foam.
My vision, hazed, runs thick with liquid tar.

I huddle, huddle back, for nothing bars
the needle puncturing this viscous dome
to seal my window where it sits ajar.

It’s dripping black between my shoulders, carves
up ridges, weeds. While yanking life from loam
my vision, hazed, runs thick with liquid tar.

The sky tonight is metal, shining stars
whose promises of soon now ring like chrome
to seal my window where it sits ajar.

A needle gushes sticky hot, too far.
Conceiving this one won’t be coming home,
my vision, hazed, runs thick with liquid tar
to seal my window where it sits ajar.


Butterfly pins

My insides are a muted shade of mauve
from top to bottom, flushed and dripping down.
A line tattooed in indigo will mark
the parted hair and where my thoughts are forced
to choose. So many sloping sides that lead
in curves, toward broad expanse of naught but flesh.

For surely underbelly counts as flesh
most tender, blooming pink from center mauve.
(A niggle-worm swells skin to itch and leads
my eyes to bite the thoughtless place it downs
blood-- mine; layers stripped away.) I am forced
by nameless ones, them-- my exposure marked

on ashy paper, proof a question mark.
The hand is cupped, but holding what? Not flesh--
that’s never certain, just easily forced.
The dot is jutting out, wrist clear as mauve.
Vast waters uncontained, they trickle down
through bones, drops aching, pulling at their lead.

A nose ahead, reigns slacken, free the lead.
I drag a stick through dirt, a jagged mark
that rapes my hands up ruddy raw and down
before they have a chance to open (flesh
or tranquilizers, all the same, spread mauve--
a haze of poppies dull and sometimes forced).

When I was younger, water drowned a force
inside me, forming scars with weights like lead
around my arms, enough to sink their mauve
enlightenments. But no one left a mark
or taught me how to swim or showed me flesh
could float-- do more than spiral, dying down.

A petal spins. I blow it up and down
with breath. In small sedated puffs, I force
a change. The time for sleep is not yet. Flesh
has fat, though thin and pocketed, that leads
me warm through cold, to kiss my pock-like marks
however angry. Yellow clears, and mauve.

Once more in downward flow, foul thoughts all lead
away and out, are forced from concave marks.
In time, my flesh will again embrace mauve.



Untitled

That first fresh itch and then we're hatching out.
We never doubt our start as eggs, of course,
before our feathers even think to sprout;
the fluffy bits are popping pyramids
of gooseflesh while our shells fall to the floor
where heels of water crush them into white.

The foaming caps and tranquil flows of white
are seen inside and once we’re fully out,
still more. Unsticking eyes from bottom floor,
we want it, oh so much, to run our course
the whole way through, to see the pyramids
amongst such brown and yet undying sprouts.

The stairs we try to climb refuse us, sprouts
instead of ivy. Trapped in membrane’s white,
we lack the knowledge that such pyramids
had needed, long ago, to be built out
of nothing. So, enrolled for the one course
we need, the years all pass and leave us floored

at gaping skips that come with brand-new floors.
Such blanks, they teach us how to carry sprouts
and homes aboard our backs. Called life’s crash-course,
the crawling shows us how to carry white
and thus escape. When out of sight, it’s out
of sight, still felt atop the pyramids.

We make our bricks and hope for pyramids
to rise up, molten-stark against the floor.
The pendulum is up and ticking out.
Dead-center brings us to a halt, we sprout
our wings, refuse to fly, spread out too white.
We’re chickens now-- we don’t intend, of course,

on going any higher than discourse.
The clock’s soft crown, the tops of pyramids
have never been reached past, the closest white
is on our heads or shed on broken floors.
We’re ready to once more have thick skins sprout,
to be the bellies tucked inside and out

the rock. We merely course across the floor,
form ice in pyramids, not cubes, and sprout
our water white inside but never out.






so there you have it. am i still supposed to pick one of the three forms to learn? i wasn't clear on that, sorry.

Aged Cherry Twizzlers


Hoodimann

PostPosted: Thu Jul 26, 2007 5:58 pm


Why don't we do a rehash of the villanelle, and then the sestina, since you've gotten your feet wet. (Haven't read your poems yet, but going to do that once I post this.)

Once we've gone over them for a bit, we'll tackle the pantoum.

Due to what is likely to be sporadic attendance here by me for the next few weeks (I'm moving back to North Carolina, etc, and while the web's there too, my access to it will likely drop temporarily.), I'll refer you to a thread here which has lots of data about the villanelle by way of my thoughts, and also by way of a link to the wikipedia site regarding villanelles.

http://www.gaiaonline.com/guilds/viewtopic.php?t=9429379

This link is from my thread where I'm mentoring Conor Olaf Barret, and we began with the villanelle as well. (If I weren't going to have sporadic attendance, I would have started you off with the sestina, but the data's already accessible and available about the villanelle.)

Don't get carried away and accidentally post in his thread...not that they're freakin' Top Secret or anything...just for clarity's sake as time goes on and more data accumulates. xp

Once you've been over the data regarding villanelles, and the nuances about the repeating lines, etc, then post new attempts here, be they whole or partial.

Feel free to post as many as you like, and to fret over them like a mother hen. However, what we'll be striving for, as an end here, is the following. Please keep in mind that this is my opinion, not a list of facts, or something measurable like a cup of sugar. However, if you are honest with yourself, you will know when you are accomplishing certain things.

Rather than just assume that practicing writing will move you to write something "new" (and who's to say something "new" even has positive value, except by refuting stagnation?), we will work under the premise that you are to be evolving, learning, growing, with your poetry a manifestation of this growth, with you able to express yourself swiftly (for the most part), accurately (regarding technical presentation), formally (knowledge of, and ability with, forms), informally (devising your own forms or merely writing free verse) and powerfully (leaving the reader a different person---on some level---than who they were before they read your poem).

Your poetry should be forceful without being heavy-handed. It should be precise without being prosaic. It should move the reader to think, on some level, "...wow...", without there being a stifling conforming to rules. It's may seem odd to refer to rules as "stifling", when we're about to delve into form poetry, which abides by strict rules, but that's okay.
Form poetry is important to learn, because by learning it, and using it, we learn a few things. We learn how to invent new forms; we learn how to express our thoughts precisely, and we also learn how to plumb the depths of the language to express what we wish to say. (Well, form poetry doesn't directly force anyone into a deeper understanding of the language, so I'll rephrase that last part.) We also learn how to sift through the language to meet the requirements asked for the form, without that sifting seeming forced or unpoetic.

Form poetry (done well) tends to get rid of most dead weight. It's quite easy to see when someone's padding a line to meet iambic pentameter...and it's quite easy to ask them to stop, and to reflect, and to show them how to rephrase so that each word carries its own weight.

I am guilty of atrocious poetry, and I apologize for it. crying

I continue to work to improve, and I hope that I always head in the right direction, despite missteps, or even because of missteps.

That's all for now. Take care. I'm excited about the prospect of working with you as well.

Chow!
PostPosted: Sun Jul 29, 2007 2:47 pm


alrighty then! i'll get reading and, hopefully soon, writing.

Aged Cherry Twizzlers


Hoodimann

PostPosted: Sun Jul 29, 2007 3:51 pm


Aged Cherry Twizzlers
alrighty then! i'll get reading and, hopefully soon, writing.


Amen. Well, I'll be here at lest a few more days. (I think.)

If you have any questions, let fly with them, please.

I looked over your poems and was impressed.

domokun
PostPosted: Wed Aug 01, 2007 2:04 pm


Crop circles

I passed the hours pressed against the grain
that rotted in my stomach, hearing sounds
and falling fast into the same refrain.

They searched the fields despite the acid rain,
the mud a second skin, and said they'd found
I passed. The hours pressed against the grain.

My mother, how could I have shown disdain
like naked skin? It left us on the ground
and falling fast into the same refrain.

I beat the stalks, the womb, I felt the pain
in giving up and bending down, was drowned.
I passed the hours pressed against the grain.

Wrong, wrong. I was alive despite the wane
of consciousness, though huddled in a mound
and falling fast into the same refrain.

The world then faded in, remorse all feigned.
The need-- it sloughed away what kept me bound.
I passed the hours pressed against the grain
and falling fast into the same refrain.

Aged Cherry Twizzlers


Hoodimann

PostPosted: Thu Aug 02, 2007 1:36 pm


Excellent job, ACT. The way you structure the phrases while keeping the repeating lines true is delicately done. I also like the way the poem ended, with a sense of both eternity and vertigo arising from the "falling fast into the same refrain".

I do not have sufficient time to go as in depth with this as I'd like, but I do have one question concerning the first stanza, and this has to do with the first and second lines.

You say "pressed against the grain that rotted in my stomach,"

I'm not wise enough to get this, despite my admonition to myself to look beyond the obvious. sad Please do me the favor of letting me know what this is supposed to indicate, because superficially I want to picture someone hiding in a field...but the "rotted in my stomach" is confusing me. (Sorry I'm so dense.) crying After rereading what I just wrote, I thought about alcohol. Is this referring to alcohol in some fashion?

Overall, you've done a great job with this, and I look forward to not only seeing your next example, but also to writing another villanelle myself which I hope is on par with yours.

(Whether I mentioned it or not, I can't recall, but it's my intention to match poems with those I mentor, in order that I may grow, and also that I may demonstrate either that I do know what I'm talking about...or that I don't know what I'm talking about! Either version should teach those I'm working with!) xd

cool

I'm impressed by your poem. I will get more in depth with it soon, but after reading it a few times, I can find scarcely anything which doesn't bear up strongly. The only thing I've found so far, I mentioned above. The rest seems solid, and it's likely only my ignorance which is preventing me from fully appreciating your beginning. Here's to hoping you aid me from my ignorance.
PostPosted: Thu Aug 02, 2007 2:44 pm


yeah, it was a reference to alcohol, but the narrator is hiding in the field as well, so. the best of both! but really, i see what you mean. hmm. i'll work on making that bit more clear.

i'm looking forward to seeing yours, too! the hardest part for me is trying to make the voice normal, like a sentence i would write regardless of structure. as soon as i've written another one, i'll post it.

Aged Cherry Twizzlers


Hoodimann

PostPosted: Sat Aug 04, 2007 3:59 pm


Aged Cherry Twizzlers
yeah, it was a reference to alcohol, but the narrator is hiding in the field as well, so. the best of both! but really, i see what you mean. hmm. i'll work on making that bit more clear.


Thank you. I'm glad I got (at least by guessing, or expressing possibilities) the other meaning involved. lol

Quote:
i'm looking forward to seeing yours, too! the hardest part for me is trying to make the voice normal, like a sentence i would write regardless of structure. as soon as i've written another one, i'll post it.


I know what you mean. That's the challenge of it, of course! xd
I've seen villanelles where the phrases continue down the lines, and I've seen them where each line is its own phrase.

I happen to think that, for purposes of focus, that it would be beneficial to try and get (just for the time being, not forever), one phrase per line. How about trying that.

Not just because that's how my simple mind interpreted it when I first learned about it, but also because I think it forces you to go deeper, by which I mean, distill the words even more, until what you have can not be replaced without damaging the poem.

Also, please keep in mind that the iambic pentameter has some flexibility in it, with regard to application. In other words, you can be one or two syllables over, here and there; or one or two syllables shy. There can also be a moment here and there when the flow isn't quite so
da-DA-da-DA-da-DA-da-DA-da-DA.

Variety was employed by the greats; it keeps monotony at bay.

Now. I have not written any new villanelles yet, and I'm due two. (One for Conor, and one for you.)

However, I'd like to know whether you've read the other ones I've written.

If not, I can post them here for you to pick at and ask me about.

Later!

Remember, asking me questions isn't a bad thing, though I don't have all the answers, for sure. lol
I will, however, find them when I need to.

ninja
PostPosted: Fri Aug 10, 2007 10:44 pm


agh i'm sorry, i haven't posted in forever!

as far as one phrase per line, i'm not sure what you mean. one sentence per line?

Aged Cherry Twizzlers


Hoodimann

PostPosted: Sun Aug 12, 2007 9:36 am


Aged Cherry Twizzlers
agh i'm sorry, i haven't posted in forever!

as far as one phrase per line, i'm not sure what you mean. one sentence per line?


I've thought about that and decided, after trying to give a couple examples of what I mean, that I was probably being a fool.

Forgive me. I did originally mean one sentence (or phrase), per line. Yes. That is indeed what I meant. I used that as a way to further refine, to find just the right word.

However, that's not really necessary.

I will return shortly. (day or two)
PostPosted: Tue Aug 21, 2007 7:13 pm


Aged Cherry Twizzlers
Crop circles

I passed the hours pressed against the grain
that rotted in my stomach, hearing sounds
and falling fast into the same refrain.


I just finished an hour-long critique which got wiped when I tried to post it. Goddamnit! *sighs* All right. It's not your fault; it's my own stupid error. Here goes again! lol

This is a good beginning. (Not much more was said the first time around here.)

Quote:
They searched the fields despite the acid rain,
the mud a second skin, and said they'd found
I passed. The hours pressed against the grain.


I'm getting images of an alien set down on our planet, due to the title and the stanzas above and below. Whether accurate or not, that's the feel I get. I like your rephrasing of the third line and wish I'd thought of that. I'm going to try it sometime.

Quote:
My mother, how could I have shown disdain
like naked skin? It left us on the ground
and falling fast into the same refrain.


Well, I can comment here instead of at the end, where this was originally. I think your "It" is too generic and that it does not pull its weight for the poem. One of the things I tend to push here the most when critiquing, is that every word in the poem must tell. If it's not working, it doesn't belong, and there are a couple ways people use weak words. Either through ignorance of a better word or ease of composition. Your use of "It" here falls into the latter category. (How?) Like so. It allows you to have a reference which refers to nothing. "It" is just thrown there without something for us to tie it to. (By the way, this stanza furthers the impression that it's about an alien, perhaps defending its actions...in which case the "It" can be seen to be a vessel of some sort.)

Now, I know you're confined to a certain syllable count, but don't feel it's a life or death issue. Having eleven or twelve syllables is not out of the question, as long as it's not the rule for the poem. (Assuming we're going with iambic pentameter as a rule for now.) It's going to be difficult to rephrase this line...but you're up to it. I've seen enough of your writing just in what you've put in this thread to know that. Go for it.

Quote:
I beat the stalks, the womb, I felt the pain
in giving up and bending down, was drowned.
I passed the hours pressed against the grain.


Good. Nothing to say here beyond that.

Quote:
Wrong, wrong. I was alive despite the wane
of consciousness, though huddled in a mound
and falling fast into the same refrain.


Good use of "wrong". You managed to bring the character from what seemed like death, in a way which is plausible. Good job, that.

Quote:
The world then faded in, remorse all feigned.
The need-- it sloughed away what kept me bound.
I passed the hours pressed against the grain
and falling fast into the same refrain.


The only other thing I have to offer is that you may wish to look at "into the same refrain" again. If you were to construe "the same" as being redundant, plausible because a refrain is a repeating of what's gone before, you could then use those syllables to descriptive advantage, instead of merely "the same", which is rather dry for such a full poem.

You might try something as blatant as "into a bleak refrain", or some other such nonsense.

Well, I'm pretty sure I got all the points I had in my original post, though surely with more brevity, which is to your benefit, I'm sure. xd

I would like to say one thing more.

This is a strong poem, and you're very close to it being a very strong poem. If I were grading it, I'd give it the weakest possible "A", with the note that you could tune it to the highest "A+". That's how I feel about it, and I hope you'll at least make the attempt...it's why we're here, isn't it?

Take care. If you have questions, pepper me with 'em!

You've been Shatnerized.

Hoodimann


Aged Cherry Twizzlers

PostPosted: Wed Aug 22, 2007 4:58 am


thankya mr. hoodie. very good points, especially the bit about the same refrain, which i hadn't thought of before. i'll have to work on editing!
PostPosted: Mon Aug 27, 2007 10:40 pm


Aged Cherry Twizzlers
thankya mr. hoodie. very good points, especially the bit about the same refrain, which i hadn't thought of before. i'll have to work on editing!


Don't erase the first version, merely repost it with "Edited version" preceding the poem.

Thankees!

(This way if any strong points from the original disappear, I'll notice.)

Hoodimann


Hoodimann

PostPosted: Tue Sep 04, 2007 2:22 am


This is a reminder to myself to write two sestinas...and soon.

domokun
Reply
Working With the Mentors (Mentor Threads)

Goto Page: 1 2 [>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum
//
//

// //

Have an account? Login Now!

//
//