|
|
| Michael Crawford or Gerard Butler? |
| Michael Crawford |
|
30% |
[ 7 ] |
| Gerard Butler |
|
69% |
[ 16 ] |
|
| Total Votes : 23 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
 Posted: Sat Jun 04, 2005 9:01 am
[ Message temporarily off-line ]
|
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sat Jun 04, 2005 10:01 am
I give them balance. Mr. Crawford has the advantage of being the origoanl, and he is a better singer. HOWEVER, our Butler has the advantage in the movie of first of having effects, though imo he looks the part of the phantom SO MUCH MORE. I give it balance, but overall, MR. Crawford got it down!
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sat Jun 04, 2005 5:53 pm
DaemonSpawn I give them balance. Mr. Crawford has the advantage of being the origoanl, and he is a better singer. HOWEVER, our Butler has the advantage in the movie of first of having effects, though imo he looks the part of the phantom SO MUCH MORE. I give it balance, but overall, MR. Crawford got it down!
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sun Jun 05, 2005 8:18 am
gerard butler, they both did a stupendous job, but i say gerard butler
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Tue Jun 07, 2005 6:07 pm
Well, I personally can't get over the original. I didn't think Gerard Butler was all that attractive and I didn't think he played a very good Erik either, but that is probably because Michael Crawford was too wonderful, in my own mind, to surpass. I don't think looks, but voice, matters. It doesn't make a difference if they're more attractive seeing as Erik is not an attractive person, at all. But he needs an absolutely spectacular voice, a hold on music so vivid that he can push people in to trances at the sound of his music, that people would call him the "Angel of Music" because it is so fantastic. I was a little disappointed in Gerard Butler's singing, but again, because my mind is set on Michael Crawford, I heard things that bugged me and I couldn't ignore them. Michael Crawford's voice is much more suited to play the part than Gerard Butler. Please understand, these are only opinions.
I respect Gerard Butler fans, however, he will never play as great an Erik as Michael Crawford did in my own mind. biggrin
O.o Michael Crawford isn't still doing Phantom though... xd
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Jun 08, 2005 7:40 am
Both. 3nodding
Butler is soooooo hot with a mask and has more a pop-voice, which added a nice touch.
Crawford is the original, and also has a beautiful voice. Crawford isn't all that hot, though...
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Jun 08, 2005 10:13 am
evilfiredevil156 gerard butler, they both did a stupendous job, but i say gerard butler It's close, but I think I'd agree with you. I do like Michael Crawford's voice-- It's a perfect tenor. But I love how rich and full Gerard Butler's sounds... It just sounds so much more powerful. sweatdrop Maybe that's just because I'm a new fan, though. I've never seen Crawford, so I can't compare them regarding looks, but I do think Butler was gorgeous in the movie.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Jun 08, 2005 1:23 pm
Zodiac Sally evilfiredevil156 gerard butler, they both did a stupendous job, but i say gerard butler It's close, but I think I'd agree with you. I do like Michael Crawford's voice-- It's a perfect tenor. But I love how rich and full Gerard Butler's sounds... It just sounds so much more powerful. sweatdrop Maybe that's just because I'm a new fan, though. I've never seen Crawford, so I can't compare them regarding looks, but I do think Butler was gorgeous in the movie. Yes. Michael Crawford does have the perfect tenor voice. But like you said, Gerard Butler has the more richer and fuller voice. It has a darker tone to it. Plus, when Crawford sings, it sounds like he's straining his voice, whereas Butler seems to have an easier time while singing. So heheh... I'd have to go with Gerard Butler on this one! And not only is Gerard Butler a wonderful singer, he's also a wonderful actor and when he did this movie, it gave me chills. THAT'S how good I thought this movie was!
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Jun 08, 2005 3:51 pm
daughter_of_the_moon2 Zodiac Sally evilfiredevil156 gerard butler, they both did a stupendous job, but i say gerard butler It's close, but I think I'd agree with you. I do like Michael Crawford's voice-- It's a perfect tenor. But I love how rich and full Gerard Butler's sounds... It just sounds so much more powerful. sweatdrop Maybe that's just because I'm a new fan, though. I've never seen Crawford, so I can't compare them regarding looks, but I do think Butler was gorgeous in the movie. Yes. Michael Crawford does have the perfect tenor voice. But like you said, Gerard Butler has the more richer and fuller voice. It has a darker tone to it. Plus, when Crawford sings, it sounds like he's straining his voice, whereas Butler seems to have an easier time while singing. So heheh... I'd have to go with Gerard Butler on this one! And not only is Gerard Butler a wonderful singer, he's also a wonderful actor and when he did this movie, it gave me chills. THAT'S how good I thought this movie was! Actually, Michael Crawford didn't have to strain his voice. It was really beautiful and controlled. Gerard Butler did not have an easier time singing. It's matter of opinion whether Crawford or Butler has a more rich and full voice. And if you listen to the soundtrack to the movie, you'll notice that Gerard Butler pronounces and stresses things wierdly. And like I said, Erik is not in the least supposed to be pretty. You can't be a genius -and- pretty. Raoul is supposed to be gorgeous, not Erik in any way whatsoever. I'll accept that Gerard Butler was good looking in your opinions but I don't see why...he really wasn't pleasing to my eyes or ears....I don't want to appear mean or rude in any way but really, I thought he made a good Phantom when you couldn't see his face well and he wasn't singing or talking. sweatdrop Please don't think poorly of me because I don't like Gerard Butler... sad
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Jun 08, 2005 4:08 pm
Malbeur daughter_of_the_moon2 Zodiac Sally evilfiredevil156 gerard butler, they both did a stupendous job, but i say gerard butler It's close, but I think I'd agree with you. I do like Michael Crawford's voice-- It's a perfect tenor. But I love how rich and full Gerard Butler's sounds... It just sounds so much more powerful. sweatdrop Maybe that's just because I'm a new fan, though. I've never seen Crawford, so I can't compare them regarding looks, but I do think Butler was gorgeous in the movie. Yes. Michael Crawford does have the perfect tenor voice. But like you said, Gerard Butler has the more richer and fuller voice. It has a darker tone to it. Plus, when Crawford sings, it sounds like he's straining his voice, whereas Butler seems to have an easier time while singing. So heheh... I'd have to go with Gerard Butler on this one! And not only is Gerard Butler a wonderful singer, he's also a wonderful actor and when he did this movie, it gave me chills. THAT'S how good I thought this movie was! Actually, I don't think anywhere did Michael Crawford really have to strain his voice. It was really beautiful and controlled. And if you listen to the soundtrack to the movie, you'll notice that Gerard Butler pronounces and stresses things wierdly. And like I said, Erik is not in the least supposed to be pretty. You can't be a genius -and- pretty. Raoul is supposed to be gorgeous, not Erik in any way whatsoever. I'll accept that Gerard Butler was good looking in your opinions but I don't see why...he really wasn't pleasing to my eyes or ears....I don't want to appear mean or rude in any way but really, I thought he made a good Phantom when you couldn't see his face well and he wasn't singing or talking. sweatdrop Please don't think poorly of me because I don't like Gerard Butler... sad
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Jun 08, 2005 4:11 pm
Muffin Lust Malbeur daughter_of_the_moon2 Zodiac Sally evilfiredevil156 gerard butler, they both did a stupendous job, but i say gerard butler It's close, but I think I'd agree with you. I do like Michael Crawford's voice-- It's a perfect tenor. But I love how rich and full Gerard Butler's sounds... It just sounds so much more powerful. sweatdrop Maybe that's just because I'm a new fan, though. I've never seen Crawford, so I can't compare them regarding looks, but I do think Butler was gorgeous in the movie. Yes. Michael Crawford does have the perfect tenor voice. But like you said, Gerard Butler has the more richer and fuller voice. It has a darker tone to it. Plus, when Crawford sings, it sounds like he's straining his voice, whereas Butler seems to have an easier time while singing. So heheh... I'd have to go with Gerard Butler on this one! And not only is Gerard Butler a wonderful singer, he's also a wonderful actor and when he did this movie, it gave me chills. THAT'S how good I thought this movie was! Actually, I don't think anywhere did Michael Crawford really have to strain his voice. It was really beautiful and controlled. And if you listen to the soundtrack to the movie, you'll notice that Gerard Butler pronounces and stresses things wierdly. And like I said, Erik is not in the least supposed to be pretty. You can't be a genius -and- pretty. Raoul is supposed to be gorgeous, not Erik in any way whatsoever. I'll accept that Gerard Butler was good looking in your opinions but I don't see why...he really wasn't pleasing to my eyes or ears....I don't want to appear mean or rude in any way but really, I thought he made a good Phantom when you couldn't see his face well and he wasn't singing or talking. sweatdrop Please don't think poorly of me because I don't like Gerard Butler... sad Yay, okay then. People at school don't like me for knowing more about Phantom of the Opera than them and expressing my opinions even though I give specific examples and they don't. I just didn't want to repeat any sort of "You're not my friend because you don't like _____!" occurances. Most people everywhere like Gerard Butler so I didn't want to get put down for liking Michael Crawford. biggrin
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Jun 08, 2005 4:13 pm
Malbeur Muffin Lust Malbeur daughter_of_the_moon2 Zodiac Sally evilfiredevil156 gerard butler, they both did a stupendous job, but i say gerard butler It's close, but I think I'd agree with you. I do like Michael Crawford's voice-- It's a perfect tenor. But I love how rich and full Gerard Butler's sounds... It just sounds so much more powerful. sweatdrop Maybe that's just because I'm a new fan, though. I've never seen Crawford, so I can't compare them regarding looks, but I do think Butler was gorgeous in the movie. Yes. Michael Crawford does have the perfect tenor voice. But like you said, Gerard Butler has the more richer and fuller voice. It has a darker tone to it. Plus, when Crawford sings, it sounds like he's straining his voice, whereas Butler seems to have an easier time while singing. So heheh... I'd have to go with Gerard Butler on this one! And not only is Gerard Butler a wonderful singer, he's also a wonderful actor and when he did this movie, it gave me chills. THAT'S how good I thought this movie was! Actually, I don't think anywhere did Michael Crawford really have to strain his voice. It was really beautiful and controlled. And if you listen to the soundtrack to the movie, you'll notice that Gerard Butler pronounces and stresses things wierdly. And like I said, Erik is not in the least supposed to be pretty. You can't be a genius -and- pretty. Raoul is supposed to be gorgeous, not Erik in any way whatsoever. I'll accept that Gerard Butler was good looking in your opinions but I don't see why...he really wasn't pleasing to my eyes or ears....I don't want to appear mean or rude in any way but really, I thought he made a good Phantom when you couldn't see his face well and he wasn't singing or talking. sweatdrop Please don't think poorly of me because I don't like Gerard Butler... sad Yay, okay then. People at school don't like me for knowing more about Phantom of the Opera than them and expressing my opinions even though I give specific examples and they don't. I just didn't want to repeat any sort of "You're not my friend because you don't like _____!" occurances. Most people everywhere like Gerard Butler so I didn't want to get put down for liking Michael Crawford. biggrin
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Jun 08, 2005 4:16 pm
Muffin Lust Malbeur Muffin Lust Malbeur daughter_of_the_moon2 Zodiac Sally evilfiredevil156 gerard butler, they both did a stupendous job, but i say gerard butler It's close, but I think I'd agree with you. I do like Michael Crawford's voice-- It's a perfect tenor. But I love how rich and full Gerard Butler's sounds... It just sounds so much more powerful. sweatdrop Maybe that's just because I'm a new fan, though. I've never seen Crawford, so I can't compare them regarding looks, but I do think Butler was gorgeous in the movie. Yes. Michael Crawford does have the perfect tenor voice. But like you said, Gerard Butler has the more richer and fuller voice. It has a darker tone to it. Plus, when Crawford sings, it sounds like he's straining his voice, whereas Butler seems to have an easier time while singing. So heheh... I'd have to go with Gerard Butler on this one! And not only is Gerard Butler a wonderful singer, he's also a wonderful actor and when he did this movie, it gave me chills. THAT'S how good I thought this movie was! Actually, I don't think anywhere did Michael Crawford really have to strain his voice. It was really beautiful and controlled. And if you listen to the soundtrack to the movie, you'll notice that Gerard Butler pronounces and stresses things wierdly. And like I said, Erik is not in the least supposed to be pretty. You can't be a genius -and- pretty. Raoul is supposed to be gorgeous, not Erik in any way whatsoever. I'll accept that Gerard Butler was good looking in your opinions but I don't see why...he really wasn't pleasing to my eyes or ears....I don't want to appear mean or rude in any way but really, I thought he made a good Phantom when you couldn't see his face well and he wasn't singing or talking. sweatdrop Please don't think poorly of me because I don't like Gerard Butler... sad Yay, okay then. People at school don't like me for knowing more about Phantom of the Opera than them and expressing my opinions even though I give specific examples and they don't. I just didn't want to repeat any sort of "You're not my friend because you don't like _____!" occurances. Most people everywhere like Gerard Butler so I didn't want to get put down for liking Michael Crawford. biggrin Aww, thanks! But I guess you can't blame them, they're only seventh graders. You can't expect much out of them....especially -these- ones. I am soo glad Friday is the last day of school. ^^
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Jun 08, 2005 4:23 pm
Malbeur Muffin Lust Malbeur Muffin Lust Malbeur daughter_of_the_moon2 Zodiac Sally evilfiredevil156 gerard butler, they both did a stupendous job, but i say gerard butler It's close, but I think I'd agree with you. I do like Michael Crawford's voice-- It's a perfect tenor. But I love how rich and full Gerard Butler's sounds... It just sounds so much more powerful. sweatdrop Maybe that's just because I'm a new fan, though. I've never seen Crawford, so I can't compare them regarding looks, but I do think Butler was gorgeous in the movie. Yes. Michael Crawford does have the perfect tenor voice. But like you said, Gerard Butler has the more richer and fuller voice. It has a darker tone to it. Plus, when Crawford sings, it sounds like he's straining his voice, whereas Butler seems to have an easier time while singing. So heheh... I'd have to go with Gerard Butler on this one! And not only is Gerard Butler a wonderful singer, he's also a wonderful actor and when he did this movie, it gave me chills. THAT'S how good I thought this movie was! Actually, I don't think anywhere did Michael Crawford really have to strain his voice. It was really beautiful and controlled. And if you listen to the soundtrack to the movie, you'll notice that Gerard Butler pronounces and stresses things wierdly. And like I said, Erik is not in the least supposed to be pretty. You can't be a genius -and- pretty. Raoul is supposed to be gorgeous, not Erik in any way whatsoever. I'll accept that Gerard Butler was good looking in your opinions but I don't see why...he really wasn't pleasing to my eyes or ears....I don't want to appear mean or rude in any way but really, I thought he made a good Phantom when you couldn't see his face well and he wasn't singing or talking. sweatdrop Please don't think poorly of me because I don't like Gerard Butler... sad Yay, okay then. People at school don't like me for knowing more about Phantom of the Opera than them and expressing my opinions even though I give specific examples and they don't. I just didn't want to repeat any sort of "You're not my friend because you don't like _____!" occurances. Most people everywhere like Gerard Butler so I didn't want to get put down for liking Michael Crawford. biggrin Aww, thanks! But I guess you can't blame them, they're only seventh graders. You can't expect much out of them....especially -these- ones. I am soo glad Friday is the last day of school. ^^
but I am almost a Sophmore in Highschool so I guess your right lol
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Thu Jun 09, 2005 5:35 pm
Muffin Lust Malbeur Muffin Lust Malbeur Muffin Lust Malbeur daughter_of_the_moon2 Zodiac Sally evilfiredevil156 gerard butler, they both did a stupendous job, but i say gerard butler It's close, but I think I'd agree with you. I do like Michael Crawford's voice-- It's a perfect tenor. But I love how rich and full Gerard Butler's sounds... It just sounds so much more powerful. sweatdrop Maybe that's just because I'm a new fan, though. I've never seen Crawford, so I can't compare them regarding looks, but I do think Butler was gorgeous in the movie. Yes. Michael Crawford does have the perfect tenor voice. But like you said, Gerard Butler has the more richer and fuller voice. It has a darker tone to it. Plus, when Crawford sings, it sounds like he's straining his voice, whereas Butler seems to have an easier time while singing. So heheh... I'd have to go with Gerard Butler on this one! And not only is Gerard Butler a wonderful singer, he's also a wonderful actor and when he did this movie, it gave me chills. THAT'S how good I thought this movie was! Actually, I don't think anywhere did Michael Crawford really have to strain his voice. It was really beautiful and controlled. And if you listen to the soundtrack to the movie, you'll notice that Gerard Butler pronounces and stresses things wierdly. And like I said, Erik is not in the least supposed to be pretty. You can't be a genius -and- pretty. Raoul is supposed to be gorgeous, not Erik in any way whatsoever. I'll accept that Gerard Butler was good looking in your opinions but I don't see why...he really wasn't pleasing to my eyes or ears....I don't want to appear mean or rude in any way but really, I thought he made a good Phantom when you couldn't see his face well and he wasn't singing or talking. sweatdrop Please don't think poorly of me because I don't like Gerard Butler... sad Yay, okay then. People at school don't like me for knowing more about Phantom of the Opera than them and expressing my opinions even though I give specific examples and they don't. I just didn't want to repeat any sort of "You're not my friend because you don't like _____!" occurances. Most people everywhere like Gerard Butler so I didn't want to get put down for liking Michael Crawford. biggrin Aww, thanks! But I guess you can't blame them, they're only seventh graders. You can't expect much out of them....especially -these- ones. I am soo glad Friday is the last day of school. ^^
but I am almost a Sophmore in Highschool so I guess your right lol we get out june 16th gonk scream gonk its not fair. i didnt know hat, that many people agreed with me, it seems nowadays everyone is turned against me (here and RL)
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Reply
![[.Multi-Colored.]'s avatar](https://a1cdn.gaiaonline.com/dress-up/avatar/ava/4a/82/6049a7161e824a_flip.png?t=1143677813_3.00_00)
