Welcome to Gaia! ::

Reply Fallacy Forum
Fallacies: A Directory (under construction)

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Cougar Trollhammer Draven

PostPosted: Wed Sep 19, 2007 10:43 pm


Index:

Post 1: Index and Overview (under construction, 25% complete)
Post 2: The Directory
Post 3: Definitions and Examples (Abstraction-Commutation) (under construction, 11% complete)
Post 4: Definitions and Examples (Composition-Modal Scope) (under construction)
Post 5: Definitions and Examples (Illicit Negative/Affirmative-Wishful Thinking) (under construction)
Post 6: reserved
Post 7: reserved


Overview:

This is an attempt at an exhaustive list of logical fallacies, both formal and informal. I will list them, then give definitions and examples for each listed.

...and I'll finish this tomorrow.
PostPosted: Wed Sep 19, 2007 10:45 pm


The Directory

Abstraction or Quoting Out of Context
Abuse of Etymology or Etymological Fallacy
Accent
Accident or Dicto Simpliciter or Sweeping Generalization
Affirmation of or Asserting the Consequent
Affirming a Disjunct/ Affirming One Disjunct or Asserting an Alternative or Improper Disjunctive Syllogism or Alternative Syllogism, Fallacy of the
Affirming the Consequent
Ambiguity
Ambiguous Middle or Four-Term Fallacy or Quaternio Terminorum
Amphiboly/ Amphibology
Anecdotal Fallacy or Volvo Fallacy
Appeal to Celebrity
Argumentum ad Baculum or Appeal to Force
Argumentum ad Consequentiam or Appeal to Consequences
Argumentum ad Hominem or Personal Attack
Argumentum ad Ignorantiam or Appeal to Ignorance
Argumentum ad Invidiam or Argumentum ad Metum or Argumentum ad Misericordiam or Argumentum ad Odium or Argumentum ad Superbiam or Appeal to Envy or Appeal to Fear or Appeal to Hatred or Appeal to Pity or Appeal to Pride or Emotional Appeal
Argumentum ad Logicam or Fallacist's/Fallacy Fallacy
Argumentum ad Naturam or Appeal to Nature or Naturalistic Fallacy
Argumentum ad Nazium or Hitler Card
Argumentum ad Populum or Appeal to Popularity or Authority of the Many or Argument by Consensus or Bandwagon Fallacy
Argumentum ad Verecundiam or Appeal to Authority or Ipse Dixit

Bad Reasons Fallacy
Base Rate Fallacy or Neglecting Base Rates
Begging the Question orCircular Argument or Circulus in Probando or Petitio Principii or Vicious Circle
Bifurcation or Black-and-White Fallacy or Black-or-White Fallacy or Either/Or Fallacy or False Dilemma

Commutation of Conditionals or Consequent, Fallacy of the or Converting a Conditional
Composition
Conjunction Effect / Conjunction Fallacy
c** Hoc, Ergo Propter Hoc

Denial of the Antecedent or Denying the Antecedent
Denying a Conjunct or Disjunctive Syllogism, Fallacy of the
Division

Equivocation or Doublespeak
Exclusive Premisses or Two Negative Premisses
Existential Fallacy/Existential Assumption, Fallacy of

Fake or False or Misplaced Precision or Spurious Accuracy
Formal Fallacy

Gambler's Fallacy or Monte Carlo Fallacy
Genetic Fallacy
Guilt by Association or Bad Company Fallacy or The Company that You Keep Fallacy

Hasty Generalization or Converse Accident

Illicit or False Conversion
Illicit Major
Illicit Minor
Illicit Process
Improper Transposition or Negating Antecedent and Consequent
Informal Fallacy

Loaded Language/Words or Question-Begging Epithets
Loaded Question or Complex Question or Many Questions or Plurium Interrogationum
Logical Fallacy

Masked Man Fallacy or Illicit Substitution of Identicals
Modal Fallacy
Modal Scope Fallacy or Scope Fallacy

Negative Conclusion from Affirmative Premisses or Illicit Negative/ Affirmative or Affirmative Conclusion from a Negative Premiss
Non Causa Pro Causa or False Cause

One-Sidedness or Card Stacking or Ignoring the Counterevidence or One-Sided Assessment or Slanting or Suppressed Evidence

Poisoning the Well
Post Hoc
Probabilistic Fallacy
Propositional Fallacy

Quantificational Fallacy
Quantifier Shift or Illicit Quantifier Shift
Question-Begging Analogy

Redefinition
Red Herring or Ignoratio Elenchi or Irrelevant Thesis
Regression/Regressive Fallacy

Slippery Slope or Beard, Argument of the/Fallacy of the
Some Are/Some Are Not or Unwarranted Contrast
Special Pleading
Straw Man
Syllogistic Fallacy

Texas Sharpshooter Fallacy
Transposition, Improper
Tu Quoque
Two Wrongs Make a Right

Undistributed Middle
Unrepresentative Sample or Biased Sample

Vagueness

Weak or False or Faulty or Questionable Analogy
Wishful Thinking

Cougar Trollhammer Draven


Cougar Trollhammer Draven

PostPosted: Wed Sep 19, 2007 10:49 pm


Definitions and Examples:

Abstraction or Quoting Out of Context

An out-of-context quote is an incomplete, and misleading, quote from another, deliberately taken to mean something other than the intended meaning by the person quoted. An example, given by Fallacy Files, is

Quote:
Have the various fossil candidates for a place in our human ancestry stood the test of time?

Answer: One by one, various fossil man finds have flashed across the front pages of the newspapers and been the subject of many scientific studies and reports, only to be at last either discredited or just forgotten, replaced by newer finds which also eventually fade away. In 1981 British scientist John Reader commented on this Hollywood character of some of our former alleged ancestors:

"Not many (if any) [fossil hominids] have held the stage for long; by now laymen could be forgiven for regarding each new arrival as no less ephemeral than the weather forecast.…"


However, the quote in question referred not to fossil hominids, but their status as the earliest known human ancestry. Inasmuch, the quote, out of context, is misleading.

Abuse of Etymology or Etymological Fallacy

The etymological fallacy is a misuse of a historical version of a word, as if that were the current word. An example is that of the word "*****". Some have been known to take it in terms of the original roots, which translate as "child love". However, the word, as used, currently refers to a disorder classified by the DSM-IV. This is related to equivocation.

Accent

A misuse of accent happens when one uses a word in a sentence which may have multiple meanings, depending on how the word is pronounced or read. Again, from Fallacy Files, "I resent that letter" may either mean "resent" as in "take offense to", or as in "sent again."

Accident or Dicto Simpliciter or Sweeping Generalization

Affirmation of or Asserting the Consequent

Affirming a Disjunct/ Affirming One Disjunct or Asserting an Alternative or Improper Disjunctive Syllogism or Alternative Syllogism, Fallacy of the

Affirming the Consequent

Ambiguity

Ambiguous Middle or Four-Term Fallacy or Quaternio Terminorum

Amphiboly/ Amphibology

Anecdotal Fallacy or Volvo Fallacy

Appeal to Celebrity

Argumentum ad Baculum or Appeal to Force

Argumentum ad Consequentiam or Appeal to Consequences

Argumentum ad Hominem or Personal Attack

Argumentum ad Ignorantiam or Appeal to Ignorance

Argumentum ad Invidiam or Argumentum ad Metum or Argumentum ad Misericordiam or Argumentum ad Odium or Argumentum ad Superbiam or Appeal to Envy or Appeal to Fear or Appeal to Hatred or Appeal to Pity or Appeal to Pride or Emotional Appeal

Argumentum ad Logicam or Fallacist's/Fallacy Fallacy

Argumentum ad Naturam or Appeal to Nature or Naturalistic Fallacy
Argumentum ad Nazium or Hitler Card


Argumentum ad Populum or Appeal to Popularity or Authority of the Many or Argument by Consensus or Bandwagon Fallacy

Argumentum ad Verecundiam or Appeal to Authority or Ipse Dixit

Bad Reasons Fallacy

Base Rate Fallacy or Neglecting Base Rates

Begging the Question orCircular Argument or Circulus in Probando or Petitio Principii or Vicious Circle

Bifurcation or Black-and-White Fallacy or Black-or-White Fallacy or Either/Or Fallacy or False Dilemma

Commutation of Conditionals or Consequent, Fallacy of the or Converting a Conditional
PostPosted: Wed Sep 19, 2007 10:50 pm


Definitions and Examples:

Composition
Conjunction Effect / Conjunction Fallacy
c** Hoc, Ergo Propter Hoc
Denial of the Antecedent or Denying the Antecedent
Denying a Conjunct or Disjunctive Syllogism, Fallacy of the
Division
Equivocation or Doublespeak
Exclusive Premisses or Two Negative Premisses
Existential Fallacy/Existential Assumption, Fallacy of
Fake or False or Misplaced Precision or Spurious Accuracy
Formal Fallacy
Gambler's Fallacy or Monte Carlo Fallacy
Genetic Fallacy
Guilt by Association or Bad Company Fallacy or The Company that You Keep Fallacy
Hasty Generalization or Converse Accident
Illicit or False Conversion
Illicit Major
Illicit Minor
Illicit Process
Improper Transposition or Negating Antecedent and Consequent
Informal Fallacy
Loaded Language/Words or Question-Begging Epithets
Loaded Question or Complex Question or Many Questions or Plurium Interrogationum
Logical Fallacy
Masked Man Fallacy or Illicit Substitution of Identicals
Modal Fallacy
Modal Scope Fallacy or Scope Fallacy

Cougar Trollhammer Draven


Cougar Trollhammer Draven

PostPosted: Wed Sep 19, 2007 10:51 pm


Definitions and Examples:

Negative Conclusion from Affirmative Premisses or Illicit Negative/ Affirmative or Affirmative Conclusion from a Negative Premiss
Non Causa Pro Causa or False Cause
One-Sidedness or Card Stacking or Ignoring the Counterevidence or One-Sided Assessment or Slanting or Suppressed Evidence
Poisoning the Well
Post Hoc
Probabilistic Fallacy
Propositional Fallacy
Quantificational Fallacy
Quantifier Shift or Illicit Quantifier Shift
Question-Begging Analogy
Redefinition
Red Herring or Ignoratio Elenchi or Irrelevant Thesis
Regression/Regressive Fallacy
Slippery Slope or Beard, Argument of the/Fallacy of the
Some Are/Some Are Not or Unwarranted Contrast
Special Pleading
Straw Man
Syllogistic Fallacy
Texas Sharpshooter Fallacy
Transposition, Improper
Tu Quoque
Two Wrongs Make a Right
Undistributed Middle
Unrepresentative Sample or Biased Sample
Vagueness
Weak or False or Faulty or Questionable Analogy
Wishful Thinking
PostPosted: Wed Sep 19, 2007 10:52 pm


(reserved)

Cougar Trollhammer Draven


Cougar Trollhammer Draven

PostPosted: Wed Sep 19, 2007 10:53 pm


(reserved)
Reply
Fallacy Forum

 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum
//
//

// //

Have an account? Login Now!

//
//