Welcome to Gaia! ::

The Fanfiction Studio

Back to Guilds

A guild for every fanfiction writer! From starters to long-time authors, here you can get tips, advertise, and more! 

Tags: fanfiction.net, archiveofourown, writing, writers, fanfiction 

Reply Fanfiction Studio
The Obligatory MARY-SUE Thread Goto Page: [|«] [<] 1 2 3 [>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Be honest: Have you ever written a Mary-Sue?
  Yes.
  No.
  Decline to State
View Results

Kendroid

PostPosted: Mon Jul 02, 2012 10:23 pm


MuffinEatinGir
Renkon Root
MuffinEatinGir
Does Bella from Twilight count or is that an out and out troll?

Most of my Oc's keep small parts, but two of my characters are unfortunately needed for plot development so I'll simply have to do my best to ensure that they don't roll over the hill of unbelievable.


Yes, Bella from Twilight is a Mary-Sue.

Its not so much the believability vs. unbelievability that makes a character a Mary-Sue. There's this wonderful thing readers and/or viewers do when they read a story or watch a movie called "willing suspension of disbelief". I am totally willing to believe that radioactive bug bites will give you superpowers instead of radiation poisoning, or that yellow sunlight would give a guy the ability to fly and shoot lazers from his eyes. What makes a character a Mary-Sue is how well readers/viewers can relate to said character. Do they still feel "human" to spite all their fantastic abilities? That is what defines a good character vs. a Mary-Sue.


.....This is actually a very confusing response....when I say believable I mean believably human.....I feel properly scolded and slightly baffled.

I feel like it was explained here pretty well. That post is kind of long though. Here's a few reasons I thought she was a Sue:
1) She has no significant flaws. Clumsiness isn't really a personality flaw; some people think it's cute.
2) She resembles Stephenie Meyer and likes the same books and music (self insert).
3) Her REAL personality flaws aren't treated as such. Bella's obsessiveness is made out to be romantic and she is still well liked even though she is manipulative.
4) Yeah, she describes herself as "plain", but all of the boys at that she comes into contact with get crushes on her almost immediately anyway.

People have brought up more points, but those are the ones that stuck out to me the most.
PostPosted: Sun Aug 05, 2012 12:55 pm


I read this awhile back, and while I don't necessarily agree with everything in it, I do find it interesting and thought maybe others might like to give it read. It is kind of long though.

150 Years of Mary Sue

Aha

Shameless Loiterer

13,750 Points
  • Survivor 150
  • Jolly Roger 50
  • Champion 300

Emo_Girl_Hitori

PostPosted: Tue Jan 22, 2013 11:11 am


A South Park fanfic of mine has a strong OC lead (I have no idea what it's really called...) but I dunno if they count as a Mary-Sue. sweatdrop Please don't kill me...
PostPosted: Tue Jan 22, 2013 9:05 pm


Emo_Girl_Hitori
A South Park fanfic of mine has a strong OC lead (I have no idea what it's really called...) but I dunno if they count as a Mary-Sue. sweatdrop Please don't kill me...

Just because an OC figures prominently in a story doesn't mean they are a Mary-Sue. So long as the story doesn't revolve solely around her/him, and she/he does things that actually move the story FORWARD you should be okay. Really, the deciding factor between an ordinary OC and a Mary-Sue is how they are portrayed, rather than what traits they actually possess, or what powers they have, or how prominently they figure in a story.

Renkon Root
Captain

Versatile Receiver

17,575 Points
  • Falling For You 25
  • Somebody Likes You 100
  • Married 100

Emo_Girl_Hitori

PostPosted: Wed Jan 23, 2013 5:54 am


Renkon Root
Emo_Girl_Hitori
A South Park fanfic of mine has a strong OC lead (I have no idea what it's really called...) but I dunno if they count as a Mary-Sue. sweatdrop Please don't kill me...

Just because an OC figures prominently in a story doesn't mean they are a Mary-Sue. So long as the story doesn't revolve solely around her/him, and she/he does things that actually move the story FORWARD you should be okay. Really, the deciding factor between an ordinary OC and a Mary-Sue is how they are portrayed, rather than what traits they actually possess, or what powers they have, or how prominently they figure in a story.

Ohh, okay. Thank you for clearing that up xd In that case, yes, they move the story along very well.
PostPosted: Sat Apr 06, 2013 10:08 pm


Here's a question: I have an OC in one of my current on-going stories that I am presenting as an adversary at first (she is the main roadblock standing in the way of the protagonist's goal), but I plan for the story to end with her turning into a begrudging* love-interest.

* By "begrudging" I mean that both parties reluctantly admit that their rivalry was (in part) due to suppressed sexual romantic frustration.

Renkon Root
Captain

Versatile Receiver

17,575 Points
  • Falling For You 25
  • Somebody Likes You 100
  • Married 100

Renkon Root
Captain

Versatile Receiver

17,575 Points
  • Falling For You 25
  • Somebody Likes You 100
  • Married 100
PostPosted: Fri Aug 30, 2013 11:45 am


Now that ff.n has added an OC option for the character tags, do you think this will increase or decrease the amount of Mary-Sues? Will it have no effect? It would just be easier to weed through them.
PostPosted: Thu Oct 31, 2013 7:56 pm


I tend to not focus on my characters that much in like describing their personalities, flaws, backgrounds, etc. I just give my characters all one flaw and personality to go on until they grow into a more dynamic character and whatnot. The prime example of me using a slightly overused Mary Su OC for Thundercats is my story, Last Life.

x Okonami x

Adorable Tipper

10,225 Points
  • Friendly 100
  • Somebody Likes You 100
  • Voter 100

GhostlyWhitePumpkins

14,950 Points
  • Trick or Treat 100
  • Happy Birthday! 100
  • Citizen 200
PostPosted: Sat Jan 25, 2014 6:45 pm


Renkon Root
Now that ff.n has added an OC option for the character tags, do you think this will increase or decrease the amount of Mary-Sues? Will it have no effect? It would just be easier to weed through them.


I think that will depend on the fandom. I've noticed some fandoms are more forgiving of Mary-Sues than others. At the same time others are so populated with them it's ridiculous.
PostPosted: Tue Jan 28, 2014 1:30 am


GhostlyWhitePumpkins
I've noticed some fandoms are more forgiving of Mary-Sues than others. At the same time others are so populated with them it's ridiculous.

I think a lot of fandoms are forgiving of OCs because some fandoms have a 'hole' where a character could be but isn't. I'm gonna use the example of Disney's Frozen since that's the most recent one I've seen. Frozen has a semi-traditional Disney ending. It wasn't 'true loves kiss' that saved the day, but it was true love (the love between sisters). But only one of the sisters got a romantic partner at the end (and its implied that they'll live happily ever after). But the other sister was left alone. Still happy. But without a romantic partner. Since there are no other canon character to pair her with (unless you want to pair her with a villain) then you'e got to create an original character. In instances like that, its more than understandable for the fandom to be forgiving of OCs. There's an actual NEED for OCs.

What really boggled my mind is when people try and create OCs in fandoms where there is no need of them at all. Fandoms like the Marvel superheroes. You want a romantic interest for a hero (any of them) they've already got at least five. You wanna give Iceman and Rouge a child? They've already got one, his name is Charles. You wanna create a futuristic AU for spiderman? It already exists, Spiderman 2099. And the same things goes for DC. Its fandoms like that, that I just can't find a justification for creating OCs. Unless you can find a nitch that hasn't already been used in canon.

Ren LehCrow

Amorous Lovergirl

7,100 Points
  • Battle: Level Up 200
  • Partygoer 500
  • Battle: Knight 100

GhostlyWhitePumpkins

14,950 Points
  • Trick or Treat 100
  • Happy Birthday! 100
  • Citizen 200
PostPosted: Tue Jan 28, 2014 12:28 pm


Ren LehCrow

I think a lot of fandoms are forgiving of OCs because some fandoms have a 'hole' where a character could be but isn't. I'm gonna use the example of Disney's Frozen since that's the most recent one I've seen. Frozen has a semi-traditional Disney ending. It wasn't 'true loves kiss' that saved the day, but it was true love (the love between sisters). But only one of the sisters got a romantic partner at the end (and its implied that they'll live happily ever after). But the other sister was left alone. Still happy. But without a romantic partner. Since there are no other canon character to pair her with (unless you want to pair her with a villain) then you'e got to create an original character. In instances like that, its more than understandable for the fandom to be forgiving of OCs. There's an actual NEED for OCs.


I completely agree.

Quote:
What really boggled my mind is when people try and create OCs in fandoms where there is no need of them at all. Fandoms like the Marvel superheroes. You want a romantic interest for a hero (any of them) they've already got at least five. You wanna give Iceman and Rouge a child? They've already got one, his name is Charles. You wanna create a futuristic AU for spiderman? It already exists, Spiderman 2099. And the same things goes for DC. Its fandoms like that, that I just can't find a justification for creating OCs. Unless you can find a nitch that hasn't already been used in canon.


I don't really read comics fanfics so I'll take your word on this. smile

I was more referring to the Anime/Manga or the Game fandom's since I read more of those. Black Butler and Resident Evil for example, I see so many Mary-Sue's there that are rarely getting called Sue's when they very much are.
On the flip side I've actually seen some beautifully created Mary-Sue's where the author actually took the time to fit her/him into the world-not make the world fit around them. It's not up anymore but a few years ago I ran across a Chris+OC fic that was actually pretty well written and very believable, I wish I knew why it was taken down. And ten years ago when I still read GundamWing fanfics where was a great one with Quater+OC.
PostPosted: Wed Feb 26, 2014 2:08 pm


Sometimes I write Mary Sues and bad plots on purpose. I find it a very good way to just practice my writing without worrying and self-censoring myself, because I tell myself, "yeah, this is gonna be really dumb, so what", and it erases some anxiety. Also sometimes what I write is really funny.

I'm not worried about writing an MS in my other fanfics, because honestly I think any character can be salvaged if they're believable and the story is told well.

Kurogiima

Timid Friend

5,650 Points
  • Money Never Sleeps 200
  • First step to fame 200
  • Friendly 100

Qaroquine

Thirteenth Pumpkin

14,450 Points
  • Jack-pot 100
  • Guildmember 100
  • Survivor 150
PostPosted: Thu Feb 27, 2014 5:31 pm


After all here and that I've read recently on Mary Sues, I don't really know how anyone could make one. I'm just being honest; I'm a bit confused. Maybe this seems like a no-brainer of something not to do because I always strive for realism...

Seriously, I used to think I had Mary Sues. And then I read just what the hell a Mary Sue is. Yeah....no. Even my self-insert fanfics lacked them entirely.

I'm trying to wrap my head around the existence of these Sues and Stus...The really bad ones, I mean. I'm going to go by people's word that good ones exist. Can't imagine how, though, by the way they sound.

I'm trying to go back in my head if I ever read a fanfiction with Mary Sue's...and I've got it. Slenderman fanfiction are RIDDLED with Mary Sues. ******** sake...So damned hard to find a good Slenderverse romance without these things!!

Yeah, I think these characters can't be taken seriously. I sure as hell can't...
PostPosted: Sun Mar 23, 2014 3:51 pm


I tried to use that mary sue test but all it really helped me with was to link me to other pages that did help. It did make me question what I was doing with my character. So I guess it's good to read questions from...

My OC is in a KH universe so when they say world or anything pertaining to that it always changing depending on where I have them going lol

xXFox QueenXx

6,950 Points
  • Beta Consumer 0
  • Beta Citizen 0
  • Beta Explorer 0

Nightmare1

Hallowed Phantom

PostPosted: Sun Sep 04, 2016 12:26 am


Ren LehCrow
What really boggled my mind is when people try and create OCs in fandoms where there is no need of them at all. Fandoms like the Marvel superheroes. You want a romantic interest for a hero (any of them) they've already got at least five. You wanna give Iceman and Rouge a child? They've already got one, his name is Charles. You wanna create a futuristic AU for spiderman? It already exists, Spiderman 2099. And the same things goes for DC. Its fandoms like that, that I just can't find a justification for creating OCs. Unless you can find a nitch that hasn't already been used in canon.


I did, actually. I have a story where the main character was someone who bullied the Scarecrow and has to deal with what he's done. Usually when bullies come up, they're either random people in flashbacks/backstory, or props for Crane's vengeance. Only Bo Griggs and Sherry Squires ever got any characterization/screen time, so that left me room to make up an OC.

But people don't often think about underutilized stories like that. They usually want romance and/or flashiness.

I will admit I have created Sues, but I have also learned and either put them on the chopping block or made them into decent characters.
Reply
Fanfiction Studio

Goto Page: [|«] [<] 1 2 3 [>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
//
//

// //

Have an account? Login Now!

//
//