Welcome to Gaia! ::

Reply United Gaians of Potterfic
Read? ..Review! Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Pink_Converse

PostPosted: Sat Sep 03, 2005 2:31 pm


feel-good-hit
Pink_Converse-
Okay, I've only read the Prologue, but that's because it's short and I'm supposed to be reading somebody else's fic ^^; But here's what I've got to say so far.
About Hermione's trip to France.. I'm pretty sure that was mentioned in the books (she took a skiing trip there for Christmas, OR she went there during the summer.. I don't remember ^^; ), and I'm glad you're making it so that it could have actually happened.
Something that caught my attention right off the bat was the CD player. Hermione was 13 when this all took place, which means that the year was around 1993.. I don't know what year exactly CD player became available to everyone, so this may or may not fit with the time period.
Even so, something that you can't really get around is the fact that the actual song ('I Wonder') was released in 2003 @_@ I suppose it isn't that big a deal, especially if the song really goes with the theme of the whole fic (I know some people base their fics entirely off of a single song) and there is no other one like it, but it's just something to keep in mind.
Hm... As for Olga being directly related to the Malfoys.. That is entirely possible. It was never mentioned in OotP where Harry was examining the tapestry that he looked further into the Malfoys' family ties, so it's still possible.
I spotted two typos in this bit:
Quote:
Hermione gained only one piece of information from his statement. She wasn't just a pureblood like Malfoy, But she was a pureblood RELATED to Malfoy! "I know him," said Hermione, "He's always making fun of me for being a muggle-born, Calling me a Mudblood!"

^^^ 'his' should be 'this', and the 'C' shouldn't be capitalized.
Also, in the sentence right after that one, the 'h' in 'he' shouldn't be capitalized either. And I think 'skied' should actually be 'skiied', but don't quote me on that ^^;
Um... You should probably capitalize 'Muggle' and 'Half-Blood', just to be politically correct, but it's not that important.

Okay, that's all I've picked out! I hope it helps/is understandable.
Oh yeah! And.. Sorry if I annoyed you ^^; You didn't really ask for a drawn-out nitpicking fest, but I don't like to see good stories suffer at the hands of careless mistakes.
ah! sweatdrop

sorry, I stink at typing... You won't believe how long it took me to get that one chapter accepted!

The song was just a filler, it didn't really mean anything. I was like, 3 when the story takes place so I gotta bone up on what kind of songs, movies, etc. got realeased then.

hey, you could have said worse stuff, I'm happy you didn't!

and about the relation, it was just something I decided to add as sort of a last minute thing. Later in the story you'll learn why she doesn't look/talk/think like malfoy and why they both hate each other... but that's all I'm saying...
PostPosted: Sun Sep 04, 2005 4:02 pm


I'm a doll *grin*. I got my story back from one person. Two more to go before I feel confident about it sweatdrop . I just need it to be...perfect, I guess. THE Regulus fic.

ode[2]sokka


Guillotein
Captain

PostPosted: Sun Sep 04, 2005 4:09 pm


RegulusofSlytherin
I'm a doll *grin*. I got my story back from one person. Two more to go before I feel confident about it sweatdrop . I just need it to be...perfect, I guess. THE Regulus fic.
Yes! That's the spirit! Make it the first brilliant Regulus fic! Every Regulus fic-writer will make it their life's work to try to make a stroy as good as this one... (okay, I'm rambling now)
PostPosted: Mon Sep 05, 2005 8:04 pm


feel-good-hit
RegulusofSlytherin
I'm a doll *grin*. I got my story back from one person. Two more to go before I feel confident about it sweatdrop . I just need it to be...perfect, I guess. THE Regulus fic.
Yes! That's the spirit! Make it the first brilliant Regulus fic! Every Regulus fic-writer will make it their life's work to try to make a stroy as good as this one... (okay, I'm rambling now)


That's it! That's exactly the idea! I want this to be the fic against which every other Regulus fic is judged. I want it to be the fic that when people read Regulus is the book, they think of. I want it to be the fic that is refurred to the most when speaking of Regulus. I want it to be the fic that anyone who is anyone has read before book 7 comes out!

*pant pant* Okay, yeah. That's my ambition. Lets see if I can do it.

ode[2]sokka


Guillotein
Captain

PostPosted: Mon Sep 05, 2005 8:24 pm


RegulusofSlytherin
feel-good-hit
RegulusofSlytherin
I'm a doll *grin*. I got my story back from one person. Two more to go before I feel confident about it sweatdrop . I just need it to be...perfect, I guess. THE Regulus fic.
Yes! That's the spirit! Make it the first brilliant Regulus fic! Every Regulus fic-writer will make it their life's work to try to make a stroy as good as this one... (okay, I'm rambling now)


That's it! That's exactly the idea! I want this to be the fic against which every other Regulus fic is judged. I want it to be the fic that when people read Regulus is the book, they think of. I want it to be the fic that is refurred to the most when speaking of Regulus. I want it to be the fic that anyone who is anyone has read before book 7 comes out!

*pant pant* Okay, yeah. That's my ambition. Lets see if I can do it.
Yes! I'll be by your side the whole way! The Grand Reggiefic Master Regulus of Slytherin and her loyal beta-reader, Spot feel-good-hit! *huffhuff*
PostPosted: Mon Sep 05, 2005 9:53 pm


*falls over giggling* Spot? I luf it! *is now going to call feel-good Spot because she loves nicknames so much*

ode[2]sokka


Guillotein
Captain

PostPosted: Tue Sep 06, 2005 3:25 am


RegulusofSlytherin
*falls over giggling* Spot? I luf it! *is now going to call feel-good Spot because she loves nicknames so much*
whee Arf!
Reply
United Gaians of Potterfic

Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum
//
//

// //

Have an account? Login Now!

//
//