Welcome to Gaia! ::

The United Forums of Gaia

Back to Guilds

 

Tags: general, discussion, chat, hangout, intelligent 

Reply The United Forums of Gaia
Anne Rice is completely insane. Goto Page: [|«] [<] 1 2 3 4 [>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

DyslexicSquirrel

PostPosted: Mon Nov 07, 2005 8:46 am


Wow. That's...That's about the funniest damn thing I've heard all year. For a woman who wrote books with S&M and implied homosexual and incestual vampire sex, that's one huge turn around. Can't wait to see this new book of hers. Is Jesus going to have hot sex with Mary and Joseph? surprised

I, mean, I've read some of Rice's books and I did like some of them, but, really, this just seems a little much.
PostPosted: Tue Nov 08, 2005 2:45 am


Well I suppose I'm happy if she indeed went down that path, I'll always respect a person for life changing choices like that. Though the premise of this next novel interests me the most, not sure if it's done before but it's a real winner. Now we'll get closer to answering what Jesus really would do. whee

Nagaki Kouji


Oberste Liebe

PostPosted: Wed Nov 09, 2005 3:22 am


Lady Pyre
Angel_Suicide

Haha, I don't blame her on the fanfic thing. I wouldn't want 13 year old bastardizing my characters either. Look at Harry Potter. XD It's not like she can really stop them, though.


From what I've heard of her later books, she bastardized her OWN characters. Who cares if someone else gets in on the action?


Haha, that's not too bad of a point. I've always just found the idea of fanfics a little uncreative on the authors part. It's always just been my opinion that if you want to write a story you should make your own characters instead of ripping off someone else's.
PostPosted: Wed Nov 09, 2005 8:36 am


Angel_Suicide
Haha, that's not too bad of a point. I've always just found the idea of fanfics a little uncreative on the authors part. It's always just been my opinion that if you want to write a story you should make your own characters instead of ripping off someone else's.

That's been my opinion as well, for a long time, but I can see situations where fanfiction isn't a bad thing.

Primarily in the realm of online fiction. Regular publishing companies tend to not even consider printing books that have been posted publically online, for example. And young authors need a place to start; sometimes creating a whole world, and characters, is a bit too complicated for them.

I've written a fanfic or two specifically to hone my skills as a writer, knowing that I would never get those particular stories published. I wrote them for the sake of writing something that people could read and give me feedback on. And I did get some good feedback; as I was writing it, chapter at a time, people would tell me what they were liking, what plots they thought needed development, where I was confusing, what they wanted to know about backstory.

... of course, when I write a fanfic, I only lift the 'world,' because I hate using other peoples' characters. Even when my characters were in a situation where they'd run into a canon character, I made up excuses. "Oh he's sick today, but here, I help you out." xd

Fanfics are no subtitute for real fiction, but damned if it isn't fun to play in somebody else's backyard.

rayinte

Invisible Loiterer

15,000 Points
  • Timid 100
  • Nerd 50
  • Invisibility 100

Wolffy000

PostPosted: Wed Nov 09, 2005 11:42 am


I don't mind fanfiction, honestly. Actually, let me rephrase, I don't mind the idea of fanfiction in itself. The execution is another matter entirely.

But it's like drawing Spiderman or something. You don't really expect to get it framed and put in a museum, but it doesn't make it less fun to draw.

The characters already have setting, and personality. Fanfiction would be there to just see little points the author may have omitted for whatever reason, or to build on something already established. Just for fun, mind you. I doubt anyone expected to get published with them.

Rice takes it way too seriously, and thats not cool. Fictional characters. Jeez, get your panties out of your a** already. It's not like you're losing anything over it.

OH NO! PEOPLE ON THE INTERNET ARE WRITING THINGS! THINGS I DISAGREE WITH! THE HORROR!
PostPosted: Wed Nov 09, 2005 11:58 am


Heh. Maybe Rice is afraid one of her fans can use her characters better than she does?

I dunno, some authors are pretty protective of their creative work for legal reasons. I mean, if they don't protect their work on all levels, then sometimes it's difficult to have a case when they want to take a particular breach of copyright to court.

Bleh. I'm reminded of the Burned for Fandom website, which detailed an artist's issues with doing free artwork based on Anne McCaffrey's Dragonriders of Pern series for members of her McCaffrey RP community. She happened to have a link to a site where she sold (real money) commissions, and she got a message from McCaffrey's laywer, pretty much a "cease and desist" because the woman was "profiting" off of McCaffrey's copywritten works.

I can't remember all of the details, but good golly. It seemed pretty much a "How to Drive Away Your Fans in Three Easy Steps" sort of thing. It's just ... stupid ... to sic lawyers on a fan because they're appreciating your work. In that particular case, she might have been actually selling commissions of her pern-based art, but of original characters. Like I said, I forget the details, and the site was missing last I looked.

Most fans, in a similar situation, would likely stop instantly if they got a personal note. Like "Your art is beautiful, but I'd really appreciate if you'd stop using my world as your subject, I'm sure you're creative enough to come up with something on your own. Loves and kisses, Your Favorite Author."

*sigh* Stuipd lawyers.

rayinte

Invisible Loiterer

15,000 Points
  • Timid 100
  • Nerd 50
  • Invisibility 100

Wolffy000

PostPosted: Wed Nov 09, 2005 12:14 pm


That can happen at times, it's not exactly unheard of. But a lot of copyright cases have to do with people incorperating other liscenses with their own products, or claiming responsibility for characters, etc.

There is something called "The Free Use" act which, while I'm a bit fuzzy on the subject, kind of boils down to "As long as you're not claiming credit for characters and/or making a profit off of a liscenced copyright then you're free to use them."

Copyright laws in themselves can get kind of fuzzy on the lines of what is legal and what isn't. But generally things like fanart and fanfiction are just dismissed until money comes into the picture. But yeah, if they really have that much of a problem, they should just send a note. Thats usually more than enough to get people to stop if you have that much trouble with it.

That being said, I think you're right. I think she was just jealous because people can, y'know, actually write good dialogue for characters and thought out plots instead of pissing off people from book to book.
PostPosted: Wed Nov 09, 2005 2:14 pm


hmm, i'm trying to figure out why i feel this way about fanworks, as i really don't know, but my feelings are strong.

if someone took one or more of my characters and wrote a story with them, i would be horrified, irritated, and upset. i'd feel like someone was taking my brain children, pieces of myself, and using them for their own devices.
however, if someone did fanart of my character (assuming it wasn't like, slash or anything, obviously) .. i'd be flattered. absolutely flattered and stunned.

i just feel like writing with someone else's character is much much more invasive than drawing them. like it's tampering with something so much more deeply. i'm not sure why that is, i'll have to give it more thought.

[Vi]x2 Section


Wolffy000

PostPosted: Wed Nov 09, 2005 5:47 pm


I don't know, for me either or is kind of terrible depending on the situation.

For me, I have a thing with non canon couples. People love to pair up characters that never shack up, ever. And it irritates the hell out of me. Don't ask why, I don't know.

Doesn't matter if it's drawn or written, it bugs the ******** out of me.

But thats the thing is that in a lot of media, like comics or movies or whatever, the same characters can be passed through a lot of people's hands. It's still the same character, just in different situations. So a well written story can be just as complimentary as a well done piece of art.

At the same time I've come across plenty of pieces of fan art that are probably worse on the characters than anything you could write about them. I've seen far too many "gender swaps" or just disgusting fanworks to justify that, well drawn or not. They still amuse me, but I could understand being bothered were I the original creator.
PostPosted: Wed Nov 09, 2005 6:58 pm


Wolffy000
I don't know, for me either or is kind of terrible depending on the situation.

For me, I have a thing with non canon couples. People love to pair up characters that never shack up, ever. And it irritates the hell out of me. Don't ask why, I don't know.

Doesn't matter if it's drawn or written, it bugs the ******** out of me.

But thats the thing is that in a lot of media, like comics or movies or whatever, the same characters can be passed through a lot of people's hands. It's still the same character, just in different situations. So a well written story can be just as complimentary as a well done piece of art.

At the same time I've come across plenty of pieces of fan art that are probably worse on the characters than anything you could write about them. I've seen far too many "gender swaps" or just disgusting fanworks to justify that, well drawn or not. They still amuse me, but I could understand being bothered were I the original creator.


Two words: Harry Potter. Just go look around fanfiction.net in the Harry Potter section. It makes me cringe. Loads of Harry/Ron, Harry/Draco, Hermione/Draco, Ron/Ginny (ew), Fred/George (also ew), and my personal favorite (not), Dumbledore/Harry.

::cringe::

---deactivated20130401---


[Vi]x2 Section

PostPosted: Wed Nov 09, 2005 6:59 pm


Cieve
Wolffy000
I don't know, for me either or is kind of terrible depending on the situation.

For me, I have a thing with non canon couples. People love to pair up characters that never shack up, ever. And it irritates the hell out of me. Don't ask why, I don't know.

Doesn't matter if it's drawn or written, it bugs the ******** out of me.

But thats the thing is that in a lot of media, like comics or movies or whatever, the same characters can be passed through a lot of people's hands. It's still the same character, just in different situations. So a well written story can be just as complimentary as a well done piece of art.

At the same time I've come across plenty of pieces of fan art that are probably worse on the characters than anything you could write about them. I've seen far too many "gender swaps" or just disgusting fanworks to justify that, well drawn or not. They still amuse me, but I could understand being bothered were I the original creator.


Two words: Harry Potter. Just go look around fanfiction.net at the Harry Potter section. It makes me cringe. Loads of Harry/Ron, Harry/Draco, Hermione/Draco, Ron/Ginny (ew), Fred/George (also ew), and my personal favorite (not), Dumbledore/Harry.

::cringe::

harry/hisOWNDEADFATHER
gonk gonk gonk
PostPosted: Wed Nov 09, 2005 7:06 pm


[Vi]x2 Section
harry/hisOWNDEADFATHER
gonk gonk gonk


eek ... gonk

I've never seen that one. But EWWW. How and why do people come up with this stuff?

---deactivated20130401---


[Vi]x2 Section

PostPosted: Wed Nov 09, 2005 7:10 pm


Cieve
[Vi]x2 Section
harry/hisOWNDEADFATHER
gonk gonk gonk


eek ... gonk

I've never seen that one. But EWWW. How and why do people come up with this stuff?

I
don't
know.
i have NEVER understood it. talk2hand
PostPosted: Wed Nov 09, 2005 8:12 pm


[Vi]x2 Section
hmm, i'm trying to figure out why i feel this way about fanworks, as i really don't know, but my feelings are strong.

if someone took one or more of my characters and wrote a story with them, i would be horrified, irritated, and upset. i'd feel like someone was taking my brain children, pieces of myself, and using them for their own devices.
however, if someone did fanart of my character (assuming it wasn't like, slash or anything, obviously) .. i'd be flattered. absolutely flattered and stunned.

i just feel like writing with someone else's character is much much more invasive than drawing them. like it's tampering with something so much more deeply. i'm not sure why that is, i'll have to give it more thought.


This is basicly the way I feel about it. Drawing a character is one thing, I'm ok with that. However, taking a character that isn't your's and assuming you'd know how they'd react to situations and such just bothers me. Other people don't know how my characters would act, I do. They're my babies, my own mind. It just.. bothers me. I can't fully explain it.

I wouldn't want someone screwing around with one of my characters anymore than I'd want someone wearing my underwear. It's just personal to me. I think whether or not a writer will approve of fanfic or not depends on how personally they hold their characters. Honestly, I can understand where Rice is coming from.

Oberste Liebe


kerminatrix

O.G. Nerd

PostPosted: Wed Nov 09, 2005 8:26 pm


see, yeah. i feel exactly this way about fanfiction. creeped out because it would make my skin crawl if someone did it with something i wrote (although presumably this would never happen because i wouldn't achieve that kind of widespread popularity, and also people only do fanfiction for certain kinds of fiction, you've probably noticed), and pissed off that someone had to bite off something i had worked hard over to show off how creative they are. if they're that creative, they should make something original. if it's bad, it's bad. that's how you start out. anyway it's not as if most fanfiction is so, um, good. i thought the internet was full of people who thought fanfiction was the kickest a** thing ever. thank god for you all.

and you want icky harry potter fanfiction matchups? i know a girl who is obsessed with hermione/snape. you see, this is because she is a very hermione person - very studious, a perfectionist, etc - and she thinks alan rickman is hot. not that there's anything wrong with finding alan rickman attractive, but when you have to make someone else's fictional characters have hot teacher/student sex just to live out your fantasies about a real live actor... yyyyyeah. i mean, i think gael garcia bernal is incredibly attractive but i don't write weird stories about humping che guevara.
Reply
The United Forums of Gaia

Goto Page: [|«] [<] 1 2 3 4 [>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
//
//

// //

Have an account? Login Now!

//
//