ZORK 3! OLD SCHOOL! lol, okay so thats a text based Apple game, I really don't claim any game as outstanding, sure some are innovative for their time but few are TRULY remarkable nowadays. even the games that get great reviews from gamespot, IGN, EGM, etc... are mostly hype and pretty graphics....
I'd liked Final Fantasy, not 10, 12 or even the rerelase of FF, no, the original NES one. I still remember sitting on my bed trying to get out of the ice caves with all my party Ko'd except a MP-less white mage. That was fun... then later doing the whitemage challenge (defeat entire game with all white mages, don't upgrade to white wizard)
Even FFtactics (not that god-awful tactics advance), rate higher than most with me. Its art was eye catching wthout taking over the game, it had an indepth story and characters you tended to care about. (I kept Mustadio in my party even though he was next to useless cause I liked the bugger)
think I'm biased towards Final Fantasy, well #3 on my list isn't an FF, its not even an RPG..... Good ol classic Mario Kart for the SNES. when released it was nice and fairly innovative...though sadly its type are a dime a dozen now. Not much can beat throwing Toad screaming along the track zipping past the slower bowser and peach
and finnally, RHapsody: a musical adventure, The music is just addictive. its a good RPG with fun characters and an interesting story... gameplay is okay, but the music.... It gets stuck in your head.
Opening (ignore the footgae, someone made a montage, but the song is intact)
http://youtube.com/watch?v=abn7ePPfSr4Villians song (see above)
http://youtube.com/watch?v=m9b2EX-qU3Y