Welcome to Gaia! ::

Reply The Pro-life Guild
Chimerism - interesting addition to the debate Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

With Motion

PostPosted: Sat Sep 16, 2006 1:08 pm


My Conscience
Beware the Jabberwock
The choicers would probably agree with you to some degree on this however, as they believe that personhood is based on your personality and all the fun stuff. Where as the common pro-life belief is that EVERY human is a person.

I believe everyone human is a person.
Pro-choicers believe the legal definition of person isn't ambiguous when it is crying
You believe that all humans are defined as a person.
You don't think the term is ambiguous either it would seem. smile
...it's only ambiguous when in a debate, because different people believe different things.
PostPosted: Sun Sep 17, 2006 9:05 pm


My Conscience
Ava R.
Chimerism is really neat. Discovery Health had a show on it a while back and it just blew my mind.

Chimeras only have on consciousness though. They may have two sets of DNA, but that doesn't mean they are actually two people. Otherwise you'd also have to argue that identical twins are really only one person since they have the same DNA.

In the episode of House M.D., the guy had 2 consciouses. One person was the normal kid, the other one was someone with a memory of being abducted by aliens. It wasn't dissociative identity disorder xd They said it was chimerism.


The kid did not have two consciouses. There were not two people.
The kid had sections of his body that were from the other set of DNA. That second set of DNA was damaged, which is why he had heart problems etc. When the boy was seeing the aliens it was not because his twin was conscious and remembering an abduction. What really happened was that part of his brain was made up of that faulty DNA and it was not working correctly. The neurons in that area were firing when they shouldn't have, and that brain activity happened to activate visual hallucinations.
Although there were two sets of DNA here there was only one conscious person. This was absolutly nothing like dissociative identity disorder.

Aiko_Kaida


My Conscience

PostPosted: Mon Sep 18, 2006 9:11 am


Aiko_Kaida
My Conscience
Ava R.
Chimerism is really neat. Discovery Health had a show on it a while back and it just blew my mind.

Chimeras only have on consciousness though. They may have two sets of DNA, but that doesn't mean they are actually two people. Otherwise you'd also have to argue that identical twins are really only one person since they have the same DNA.

In the episode of House M.D., the guy had 2 consciouses. One person was the normal kid, the other one was someone with a memory of being abducted by aliens. It wasn't dissociative identity disorder xd They said it was chimerism.


The kid did not have two consciouses. There were not two people.
The kid had sections of his body that were from the other set of DNA. That second set of DNA was damaged, which is why he had heart problems etc. When the boy was seeing the aliens it was not because his twin was conscious and remembering an abduction. What really happened was that part of his brain was made up of that faulty DNA and it was not working correctly. The neurons in that area were firing when they shouldn't have, and that brain activity happened to activate visual hallucinations.
Although there were two sets of DNA here there was only one conscious person. This was absolutly nothing like dissociative identity disorder.

Ah...
I just pointed out D.I.D. to make sure someone doesn't say it could be that sweatdrop
So, it's like what I said eariler. One zygote make certain lobes of the brain and another one made the other lobes?
PostPosted: Mon Sep 18, 2006 10:22 am


My Conscience
Aiko_Kaida
My Conscience
Ava R.
Chimerism is really neat. Discovery Health had a show on it a while back and it just blew my mind.

Chimeras only have on consciousness though. They may have two sets of DNA, but that doesn't mean they are actually two people. Otherwise you'd also have to argue that identical twins are really only one person since they have the same DNA.

In the episode of House M.D., the guy had 2 consciouses. One person was the normal kid, the other one was someone with a memory of being abducted by aliens. It wasn't dissociative identity disorder xd They said it was chimerism.


The kid did not have two consciouses. There were not two people.
The kid had sections of his body that were from the other set of DNA. That second set of DNA was damaged, which is why he had heart problems etc. When the boy was seeing the aliens it was not because his twin was conscious and remembering an abduction. What really happened was that part of his brain was made up of that faulty DNA and it was not working correctly. The neurons in that area were firing when they shouldn't have, and that brain activity happened to activate visual hallucinations.
Although there were two sets of DNA here there was only one conscious person. This was absolutly nothing like dissociative identity disorder.

Ah...
I just pointed out D.I.D. to make sure someone doesn't say it could be that sweatdrop
So, it's like what I said eariler. One zygote make certain lobes of the brain and another one made the other lobes?


It wasn't whole lobes. I believe it was just one small portion of the child's brain that was made up of the defective DNA. I can't remember where they showed the damaged area being during the show, but with those kind of hallucinations it should have been a small portion of the occipital lobe.

Aiko_Kaida

Reply
The Pro-life Guild

Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
//
//

// //

Have an account? Login Now!

//
//