i_heart_ron
That may have been my biggest problem with HBP...I
did not like Harry being "right."
Me neither. He's wrong way too often, after a while I just come to expect it.
FireHorseDemon
I dont know. it's really hard to think that dumbledore would of been that wrong about snape. I dont really think that he planed to die because he would of told someone but then again who ever said that he was REALLY dead. couldent dumbledore have a horcrux? (if it said that he didn't in the book i'm sorry about that i just cant rember.)
Dumbledore either says or implies that making a horcrux is dark, evil magic. I cannot imagine him ripping his own sould apart.
On a slightly off-topic note: Does anyone have a different "view" of Snape between movie and book? In the book, I hate him for how unfair his is. In the movies, a lot of his cruelty is left out and I find myself liking his wit. Am I the only one?
neutral
Reply
