Welcome to Gaia! ::

<3 </3

Do you think cold fusion is effective?

Yes. 0.31034482758621 31.0% [ 9 ]
No. 0.41379310344828 41.4% [ 12 ]
Moneymoneymoneymoneymoneymoneymoney 0.27586206896552 27.6% [ 8 ]
Total Votes:[ 29 ]
1

Wikipedia article

I'm having trouble understanding cold fusion. The first time I heard about it was back in 2003 when I was playing Command & Conquer : Generals. And then I heard from someone near me at the time that cold fusion is "the ability to power an entire city with just a glass of water".

But everytime I look up something on cold fusion, I get things that I don't understand, and irrelevent pictures. And yet, from whatever source I could find, they are saying that cold fusion, although originating in science fiction, is actually possible. Supposedly the US Navy even successfully tested a cold fusion reactor (or something) in the early 80's or late 70's.

People are saying that cold fusion is cleaner and more efficient. Cleanliness would be nice and it would calm down disgruntled environmentalists who gripe about global warming. But what if cold fusion isn't as effective as, say, nuclear power? In fact, cold fusion is semi-nuclear....then again I only assume this because H2O includes hydrogen, which is a nuclear element (at least when it comes to nuclear weapons but...). It confuses me really; does that make oxygen nuclear too? I doubt it somehow.

Anyone want to discuss and possible help me out? I'm curious, but it's fun research.
As far as anyone can tell, cold fusion is based on the process of fusing deuterium, i.e. hydrogen-2, nuclei into...no one's sure yet.
The water bit is just a means of forcing this reaction to occur in a stable setting. So the oxygen is not a nuclear material in that it doesn't react on a nuclear level. The electrolyzing process breaks apart the heavy water into deuterium nuclei and deuterium-oxide ions, and only the deuterium nuclei react.

Cold fusion would be cleaner than normal hot fusion because it seems to be more energy efficient and doesn't leak radiation as much, at least based on current experimental evidence.

Unfortunately, said experimental evidence is sadly sporadic and scarce, and no one is really sure where all the energy released by the nuclear reaction is coming from as no one is sure what the nuclear reaction is. None of our current explanations match the observed products of the reaction.
Most of the point is that supposedly a reaction occured, where more energy came out of a reaction that was put IN.
My attitude toward cold fusion is that until someone proves that it can be done, it's just a theory--or at worst, wishful thinking. Although a number of scientists believe that cold fusion is possible and more than a few claim to have succeeded where others have failed, no one has yet to repeat their experiments under laboratory conditions. Until that happens, I will remain skeptical.
I like the idea of powering an entire city with simply a glass of water. It sounds crude, but unimaginable too. But it is possible that some of our current power sources will remain more effective than even cold fusion. Then again, I'm not a rocket scientist. sweatdrop
godhi
My attitude toward cold fusion is that until someone proves that it can be done, it's just a theory--or at worst, wishful thinking. Although a number of scientists believe that cold fusion is possible and more than a few claim to have succeeded where others have failed, no one has yet to repeat their experiments under laboratory conditions. Until that happens, I will remain skeptical.

Exactly. I'm all for wishful thinking, don't get me wrong, but in science it's kind of important to be able to reproduce the results of the experiment.
Please bear in mind this is entirely from one Physics lesson about cold fusion- I am not an expert! As far as I can tell, cold fusion is nuclear fusion happening without the high energy levels needed. Some scientists said they could do it, but when other scientists tried to recreate the conditions the experiment failed, meaning that cold fusion couldn't be proven one way or the other
Right ok... You know how nuclear FISSION works right? You get a Uranium isotope atom. (Big fat hefty atom) and split it in two because it's such a large heavy atom it releases a who crap load of energy.

Nuclear fission, Has its downside the large atoms left behind are radioactive and Uranium metal is difficult to find and even more difficult to refine.

The opposite is true with really small atoms. If you smash two small atoms together and form a larger FUSION of the two atoms a whole crapton of energy is released.

What we use in FUSION reactions is hydrogen or its isotopes. (Deuterium or Tritium) Problem is atoms of ANY element not just hydrogen don't like fusing together due to the laws of physics The central cores and nucleolus of the atom (The parts of the atom we need to fuse) Repel each other like magnets.

So in order to get them to fuse normally you need to expose them to completely Insane conditions. This usually takes the form of "HOT FUSION" This is where you head the hydrogen isotopes to several time the temperature of the sun and smash them into each other in a fangled machine. This process of heating atoms this much uses alot of energy at present more than the actual fusion of the hydrogen atoms dose already. Thusly functional HOT FUSION power plants don't exist yet.

COLD FUSION could be said to be a holy grail, However Fevered dream is more accurate a description, It claims that you don't need to heat hydrogen upto those insane conditions and you can infact manipulate hydrogen into fusion without huge energy investment costs.

They say "powered by water" because Waters chemical composition is H2O
two hydrogen atoms and an oxygen Atom thusly in water there is ALOT of hydrogen for potential fusion.
godhi
My attitude toward cold fusion is that until someone proves that it can be done, it's just a theory--or at worst, wishful thinking. Although a number of scientists believe that cold fusion is possible and more than a few claim to have succeeded where others have failed, no one has yet to repeat their experiments under laboratory conditions. Until that happens, I will remain skeptical.
check it out.
Real garage Physics sorta stuff, low budget, uses 3 significant figures more than he can measure effectively in his calculations, but it's unmistakable.

Twice as much Energy comes out as is put it.

And he repeats it 2 or 3 times.

There's footage too.
Cold fusion may or may not work...the reason it can't be said for sure either way is, no body has been able to independantly verify that any specific method works, and so we have several seperate people who say they can do it whenever they want, but nobody else tried their method to see if it worked...and of course its been shown that people aren't above lying in order to get fame, especially for discovering the Holy Grail of energy sources.
Cromdog
Cold fusion may or may not work...the reason it can't be said for sure either way is, no body has been able to independantly verify that any specific method works, and so we have several seperate people who say they can do it whenever they want, but nobody else tried their method to see if it worked...and of course its been shown that people aren't above lying in order to get fame, especially for discovering the Holy Grail of energy sources.
¬_¬

Did you honestly not notice my post at all?
Despite it being just above yours?

If some guy can verify the experiment in his Lab on a shoestring budget and take amateur footage of it, I'd say it qualifies as independant reproduction.

The problem is that we have no idea what's actually going on.

More energy comes out than what's put in, we see a big glowing light and lots of steam.... but there is nothing to indicate exactly what's going on.
Asside from that it's Nuclear (Radiation scarring on plastic discs put in with one of the experiments) we don't know s**t about it.
Darkphantom
This is where you head the hydrogen isotopes to several time the temperature of the sun and smash them into each other in a fangled machine.


The sun IS a big fussion reactor. I think you can use a sligtly lower temperature then the suns core though. (most of the reaction is taking place there)

I do not think that the experiment shown abouve is cold fussion. If it was that simple we would be using it by now.
Captain Wolff
Darkphantom
This is where you head the hydrogen isotopes to several time the temperature of the sun and smash them into each other in a fangled machine.


The sun IS a big fussion reactor. I think you can use a sligtly lower temperature then the suns core though. (most of the reaction is taking place there)
For traditional Fusion you can do it at room Temperature if you wanted to - you'd just need it at an unimaginable pressure is all.

Captain Wolff
I do not think that the experiment shown abouve is cold fussion. If it was that simple we would be using it by now.
Iit doesn't matter whether it's Cold Fusion or Free Energy or even some wierd Chemical Reaction - all we know is that it gives out more Energy than it takes in.

It's been reproduced all over the place - Google it.
There are Universities and garages all over the World with little reactors in them.

As for why it's not been commercialised, well... that's easy; the Tungsten Electrodes get eroded.
Apparently it's difficult to fix.
nuclear is a force in the atom that keeps the atom together so you could say that hydrogen is the only nonnuclear element xp and i think the cup of water comment is about zero point energy

Quick Reply

Submit
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
//
//

Join Now

// //

Have an account? Login Now!

//
//