Welcome to Gaia! ::

After reading the first post, do you think that docking and or cropping should be illegalized?

Yes, I believe that both docking and cropping should be made illegal. 0.25195173882186 25.2% [ 355 ]
I believe that docking should be illegalized but cropping should remain legal. 0.015613910574876 1.6% [ 22 ]
I believe that cropping should be illegalized but docking should remain legal. 0.075230660042583 7.5% [ 106 ]
No, I believe that both cropping and docking should remain legal. 0.16962384669979 17.0% [ 239 ]
I am ambivalent on this issue. 0.15330021291696 15.3% [ 216 ]
I have not read the first post. 0.33427963094393 33.4% [ 471 ]
Total Votes:[ 1409 ]
1 2 3 4 5 6 ... 20 21 22 > >>

Bravo.

I'm all for docking or cropping. I'd prefer it if there were a "reason" for it (such as "this dog will be a working dog and a tail would be an encumberment" wink , but aesthetics is a fine reason, too. Edit: Forgot to say (Eggy's post reminded me), as long as it's done by a trained professional.

If you are against docking or cropping, wouldn't you also be against circumcision, piercing babies' ears, etc? Since the only reason I can think of is "They haven't got a choice in the matter!"

7,350 Points
  • Wall Street 200
  • Prayer Circle 200
  • Nudist Colony 200
Docking and cropping are fine as long as they are done by a vet. Some dogs breed standard requires either docking or cropping or both.
Huh. I think both are perfectly acceptable. For whatever reason, other than cruelty, of course. Also, I don't see how balance can play into this. A table has the same number of legs as a dog, and it stays standing just fine without ears.
Nonesuch Solo
Bravo.

I'm all for docking or cropping. I'd prefer it if there were a "reason" for it (such as "this dog will be a working dog and a tail would be an encumberment" wink , but aesthetics is a fine reason, too. Edit: Forgot to say (Eggy's post reminded me), as long as it's done by a trained professional.

If you are against docking or cropping, wouldn't you also be against circumcision, piercing babies' ears, etc? Since the only reason I can think of is "They haven't got a choice in the matter!"

Don't forget neutering. I've actually had people that were all 'but they should keep what God gave them' but went all shifty-eyed when I brought up neutering in the last thread.

Piotr: You'd be surprised how much balance is cited as a reason; I think people are mainly thinking of cats when they say that and don't realize that it doesn't hold true for dogs.

Karen, please, please do not bump or spam in this thread. This is ED, not the Chatterbox.

Eloquent Gawker

Yay. :3

I completely support docking. It causes the puppies no trauma, and most arguments against it just don't hold up. I do think that it needs to be done by a veterinarian, as mentioned earlier, because botched dockings can be very painful for the dog.

I can personally attest to the fact that docked tails, or cropped ears, do not interfere with doggy communication. I used to work at a kennel, and supervised hundreds of play groups while I was there. Dogs with docked tails were never at a disadvantage in play, nor did they have trouble conveying thier emotions. Some of the most doggy-friendly, hardest-playing dogs there had docked tails.
I have no problem with docking or cropping once it's done by a vet.

My Yorkie's tail is docked and honestly I couldn't imagine it any other way. My uncle has an undocked yorkie/schnauzer mix (both breeds are typically docked) that has a very long, thin tail and he's injured his tail may times. I cringe everytime I hear his tail crack off of something.

I also know an Australian Cattle Dog (working dog) that had his tail injured and had to be amputated, but he can still do his job just as well and an undocked dog. The broken tail hurt more than the actual docking procedure.

As far as balance goes, my docked Yorkie can jump straight up onto the back of the couch and easily walk along the back without a problem. I can't say the same for my uncle's undocked dog.
All five of my dog's tails are docked. I nearly shot myself when my old lab's tail would slap me on the leg. -.- Couldn't stand that.
Enishi-san
All five of my dog's tails are docked. I nearly shot myself when my old lab's tail would slap me on the leg. -.- Couldn't stand that.

As it happens, every dog I can ever remember living with except the most recent addition to my home has also had a docked tail as well, and the last one probably has a naturally bobbed tail (he's a mutt and shows other conformational signs of having Pembroke Welsh Corgi in him, and as he was found wandering on a road we have no idea otherwise), so...yeah. That's why I redid the thread as opposed to a few of the other regs in the old ones.
Sola Catella
Don't forget neutering. I've actually had people that were all 'but they should keep what God gave them' but went all shifty-eyed when I brought up neutering in the last thread.


Indeed.

If it's an issue of consent or "keeping what God gave them" then we should not take away their ability to procreate.

Also, if we discuss "keeping what God gave them" we have to wonder about all the genetic defects he gave 'em. Should we just let them suffer with whatever disability they're born with?
I'm good with docking the tail, it serves a purpose in most cases and causes the puppy very little inconvience. It doesn't hinder communication with other dogs or with their handlers.

However, I've found that cropping is largely for cosmetic purposes and serves little purpose in todays dog. And in my opinion, your taking a riskof going for one look with your pup, but getting a "mutilated look". I have seen more bad crops than good..and since we run a grooming shop...I have a pretty good basis for comparison.

Eloquent Gawker

razorgod
I'm good with docking the tail, it serves a purpose in most cases and causes the puppy very little inconvience. It doesn't hinder communication with other dogs or with their handlers.

However, I've found that cropping is largely for cosmetic purposes and serves little purpose in todays dog. And in my opinion, your taking a riskof going for one look with your pup, but getting a "mutilated look". I have seen more bad crops than good..and since we run a grooming shop...I have a pretty good basis for comparison.


I've seen a lot of really bad Miniature/ Standard Schanuzer ears lately. They look like AmStaff ears, but shorter- We've even had trouble clipping near the ears, because the edge is so close to the inner ear. I don't necessarily support cropping, as it does serve little to no purpose unless a dog is doing the work it was bred for.

In some breeds, I can't understand why they still crop- AmStaffs and APBTs, for example. Aren't we trying to get away from the whole "fighting dog" image? gonk
docking an d cropping are not necessary for hygiene.

their only purpose is to help the animals "conform to breed".

its like topiary on sensitive live animals.

its unnecessary and cruel.

Rainbow Raider

10,000 Points
  • Cheerbringer 100
  • Heckler 50
  • Way Too Many Pies 300
One of the reasons's the tail is shortened is because of the sheer power contained in the dog's tail. My bf's family has a Rottweiler and there's a hell of lot of strength in the stub that remains of her tail. If a Rottweiler were allowed to keep its full tail, it could easily bruise a full-grown person's leg, knock a child of their feet and cause an extreme amount of damage to household properties.

Maybe it seems cruel, but I would think that the problems caused by a full tail would far outweigh the "cruelty" factor. Provided it's done by a vet, there's nothing really wrong with it.

As for cropping the ears, I really can't say anything about that, aside from the fact that I don't really see a point.

No pun intended. mrgreen

Quick Reply

Submit
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
//
//

Join Now

// //

Have an account? Login Now!

//
//